-
Thea Riofrancos @triofrancos outlines the rising conflicts over minerals and mining for the green energy transition. theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/jun/14/electric-cost-lithium-mining-decarbonasation-salt-flats-chile
-
Some key points… renewable energy, energy storage, electrification of transport, and enlarging the power grid to replace on-site burning of fossil fuels for heating all have mineral (mostly metal) demands. The IEA attempted to quantify these… iea.org/reports/the-role-of-critical-minerals-in-clean-energy-transitions
-
As Riofrancos points out, the scale of these demands depends on how much individual products continue to predominate over collective solutions, with cars vs mass transit as perhaps the best example.
-
"One report estimates that the mining sector produces 100bn tons of waste every year. Extraction and processing are typically water- and energy-intensive, and contaminate waterways and soil."
-
This is both a problem in terms of the industry's orientation, and an opportunity for emissions reductions… There's a lot of unnecessary mining that could be avoided thru reduced consumption and greater recycling.
-
However, a couple of limits to Riofrancos' argument: 1. The transition from mining fuel to mining energy capturing materials represents a huge decrease in the total volume needed for energy.
-
There's simply no comparison between the massive displacements implied by coal mining and the rotor, turbine, and battery replacements for them.
-
2. Minerals w/o long histories of extraction are often available in higher concentration sites, requiring less processing than minerals (like gold, silver) that have largely been stripped from the Earth already.